#19 - Second Billiard Attempt - feedback appreciated
Posted: Fri Sep 01, 2017 9:07 am
As mentioned in my other thread, I've decided that for the foreseeable future I'll be building pipes in pairs: one billiard for learning and one 'fun' one to try to better satisfy my creative urges while I try to mimic the shapes I see online and in my head. Here's the billiard. My self critique is below - I'll point out the specific things that I know I struggled with - hopefully this will let you guys know where I know I've missed the mark so you don't have to waste time repeating things.
As with the other thread, sorry that the pictures are garbage.
The Good:
1. This was my first time hitting the airway perfectly centered.
2. Looks much closer to being a billiard than my previous effort.
3. Bite zone proper thickness and I did a better job of getting it flatter and non-footballish.
4. Finish in general is worlds better than the last one. Amazing what a difference it makes not doing all buffing and waxing at 3500 RPMs
The Bad:
1. I needed more off the chin and back of the bowl. I undershot the chin a fair bit because I tried a thinner oval shank this time, and visually pushing the shape a little more brandy-ish looked right at the time.
2. Taper on the underside of the stem bulges/blimps out a little.
3. As with the other one, quality of the polish on the stem is not yet where it needs to be.
4. The shank and stem taper toward the button instead of being proper straight lines (which would have put the button at ~17mm wide - big but still okay I think?)
The Ugly:
1. This was the first stem I drilled on the lathe, and the bit bent and wandered when I was drilling for the tenon - so it ended up too big, so the tenon was a little off center, so the airway is a little off-center. It's so terrible that I'm not including a picture.
2. As with the other one, the button is huge - and worse, I cut the slot a little off-angle. I tried to open it up a bit to even it out, but the internals are off and now the slot is huge and shitty looking.
3. There's something sort of funky with the taper down to the bite zone - I tried to pay attention to all my glare lines but I don't think I got things even enough as the cross-sectional shape changed to get down flat.
And just because I'm a smartass - here's my attempt at a pre-emptive LL/Sas'd side view shot:
Thanks again as always, everyone.
As with the other thread, sorry that the pictures are garbage.
The Good:
1. This was my first time hitting the airway perfectly centered.
2. Looks much closer to being a billiard than my previous effort.
3. Bite zone proper thickness and I did a better job of getting it flatter and non-footballish.
4. Finish in general is worlds better than the last one. Amazing what a difference it makes not doing all buffing and waxing at 3500 RPMs
The Bad:
1. I needed more off the chin and back of the bowl. I undershot the chin a fair bit because I tried a thinner oval shank this time, and visually pushing the shape a little more brandy-ish looked right at the time.
2. Taper on the underside of the stem bulges/blimps out a little.
3. As with the other one, quality of the polish on the stem is not yet where it needs to be.
4. The shank and stem taper toward the button instead of being proper straight lines (which would have put the button at ~17mm wide - big but still okay I think?)
The Ugly:
1. This was the first stem I drilled on the lathe, and the bit bent and wandered when I was drilling for the tenon - so it ended up too big, so the tenon was a little off center, so the airway is a little off-center. It's so terrible that I'm not including a picture.
2. As with the other one, the button is huge - and worse, I cut the slot a little off-angle. I tried to open it up a bit to even it out, but the internals are off and now the slot is huge and shitty looking.
3. There's something sort of funky with the taper down to the bite zone - I tried to pay attention to all my glare lines but I don't think I got things even enough as the cross-sectional shape changed to get down flat.
And just because I'm a smartass - here's my attempt at a pre-emptive LL/Sas'd side view shot:
Thanks again as always, everyone.