How thin is thin enough- Shellac
-
- Posts: 1346
- Joined: Tue Jan 10, 2012 4:55 pm
- Contact:
How thin is thin enough- Shellac
Alright, so I've heard tales of sealing the top coat of shellac in a contrast stain via shellac *gasp*. Now, my question, is how thin do we want said shellac? Do we want to even be able to see it? Should it just be a thin shiny shell? Or after the shellac dries should the wood look almost the same? I think I may have my shellac too thinned out right now, when it goes on you cannot even tell there was ever shellac. The last thing I want is to take my hard work to the tripoli and have my yellow all buff off. Help!
Re: How thin is thin enough- Shellac
Are you using the same type (spirit/water) of dye for both colours?
- KurtHuhn
- Site Admin
- Posts: 5326
- Joined: Thu Nov 23, 2006 8:00 pm
- Location: United States/Rhode Island
Re: How thin is thin enough- Shellac
There is so much misinformation and bullshit out there with regards to shellac. Unless it's another pipe maker telling you something about it, you should probably disregard every word. If it IS a pipe maker, take it all with a grain of salt.
The way you apply shellac to a smooth pipe is to quickly wipe it on, count to about 7, then wipe it all off again. This leaves only a teensy amount on the wood, and it's really just there to help lock the stain in place and provide a consistent surface for your final finishing. You still need to polish and buff on carnuba - which is what makes the pipe shiny.
In terms of the relative viscosity of shellac? I dunno. I redneck it. I take a half-pint mason jar, pour in flakes to fill it most of the way, then pour denatured alcohol up to the headspace line (to cover the flakes). Seems to work for me.
You do not want to have a "shell" finish of shellac on a smooth pipe. It will wear unevenly (all finishes wear) and look like utter crap, especially on heavily used pipes.
The way you apply shellac to a smooth pipe is to quickly wipe it on, count to about 7, then wipe it all off again. This leaves only a teensy amount on the wood, and it's really just there to help lock the stain in place and provide a consistent surface for your final finishing. You still need to polish and buff on carnuba - which is what makes the pipe shiny.
In terms of the relative viscosity of shellac? I dunno. I redneck it. I take a half-pint mason jar, pour in flakes to fill it most of the way, then pour denatured alcohol up to the headspace line (to cover the flakes). Seems to work for me.
You do not want to have a "shell" finish of shellac on a smooth pipe. It will wear unevenly (all finishes wear) and look like utter crap, especially on heavily used pipes.
Re: How thin is thin enough- Shellac
I wipe it on super thin, let it dry, and then grind/polish with tripoli.
It's .... just barely there, when it's dry.
It's .... just barely there, when it's dry.
ALL YOUR PIPE ARE BELONG TO US!
- archaggelosmichail
- Posts: 188
- Joined: Thu Jul 14, 2011 11:11 am
- Location: Paros, Greece
- Contact:
Re: How thin is thin enough- Shellac
When it comes to smooth pipes, what type of shellac cut, do you use?
Re: How thin is thin enough- Shellac
I've had success taking a 5 lb cut and diluting it by probably 3 or 4 times, so I'd guess I'm talking about a 1 lb cut or less.
ALL YOUR PIPE ARE BELONG TO US!
- KurtHuhn
- Site Admin
- Posts: 5326
- Joined: Thu Nov 23, 2006 8:00 pm
- Location: United States/Rhode Island
Re: How thin is thin enough- Shellac
That's my guess as well. I think Todd J. suggested that cut several years ago, so that's roughly what I use.
-
- Posts: 12
- Joined: Mon Jul 02, 2012 6:10 pm
Re: How thin is thin enough- Shellac
Shellac < bug shit finish is not durable other finishes are.
hard finishes can yellow, chip and scratch, but they show the wood grain the best and protect the wood. But dont do well with heat.
Longneckers
hard finishes can yellow, chip and scratch, but they show the wood grain the best and protect the wood. But dont do well with heat.
Longneckers
Re: How thin is thin enough- Shellac
Shellac melts at around 65 degrees C - far too hot to touch. So if anyone "melts" the finish on a pipe, they've burnt the inside of the bowl most likely.
There are certainly more durable finishes, and lots of them are reasonably compatible with pipe making. And you can slop a heavy coat of varathane on your next pipe if you don't like bug shit, longneckers, and just see how the customer likes it.
I think it's pretty important to note that no one is doing a "shellac finish" - french polishing a pipe is basically impossible. What we are suggesting is that some kind of hardening impregnator needs to be used to set the stain on a pipe.
There are certainly more durable finishes, and lots of them are reasonably compatible with pipe making. And you can slop a heavy coat of varathane on your next pipe if you don't like bug shit, longneckers, and just see how the customer likes it.
I think it's pretty important to note that no one is doing a "shellac finish" - french polishing a pipe is basically impossible. What we are suggesting is that some kind of hardening impregnator needs to be used to set the stain on a pipe.
ALL YOUR PIPE ARE BELONG TO US!
- staffwalker
- Site Supporter
- Posts: 391
- Joined: Thu Nov 23, 2006 8:00 pm
- Location: USA, texas
Re: How thin is thin enough- Shellac
Sorry, I don't buy it. All you guys who maintain you are using Shellac but are doing so solely to set the stain should be in politics. You are experts at 'double-talk'. Why don't we all be honest and simply state, "I use Shellac because it leaves a superior shine, one I can get no other way". A table at a show with a bunch of 'shiny' pipes draws customers and sales. bob gilbertSasquatch wrote:
I think it's pretty important to note that no one is doing a "shellac finish" - french polishing a pipe is basically impossible. What we are suggesting is that some kind of hardening impregnator needs to be used to set the stain on a pipe.
- Tyler
- Site Supporter
- Posts: 2376
- Joined: Thu Nov 23, 2006 8:00 pm
- Location: Farmersville, TX
- Contact:
How thin is thin enough- Shellac
Well, I don't think that's true Bob. I haven't used shellac in quite some time, so I don't really have a dog in the hunt, but I wouldn't get a better shine when I used it.
Tyler Lane Pipes
http://www.tylerlanepipes.com
http://www.tylerlanepipes.com
Re: How thin is thin enough- Shellac
Bob I think the difference you're not indicating here is that there's such a thing as a shellac finish, where you apply layer after layer of shellac and are constantly re-dissolving the lower layers and sort of polishing as you go, and you wind up with umpteen layers of shellac and it's shiny as hell. Let's call this French Polish. What's going on with the pipes is nothing like that.
Yeah, I get a shinier finish when I use shellac, and that's because it offers a very smooth base for the wax, and has done some microscopic fill work on the wood, leaving a very smooth surface after polishing. But the amount of shellac on the pipe after the polish is.... god, it's miniscule.
Like Tyler (and probably totally unlike Tyler) I have moved away from shellac in a lot of applications too.
But if you are topstaining, you need to get the stain to stay on/in the wood, it's that simple. Yeah, there's another benefit - it makes shining the pipe up that much easier, so what's not to like?
Yeah, I get a shinier finish when I use shellac, and that's because it offers a very smooth base for the wax, and has done some microscopic fill work on the wood, leaving a very smooth surface after polishing. But the amount of shellac on the pipe after the polish is.... god, it's miniscule.
Like Tyler (and probably totally unlike Tyler) I have moved away from shellac in a lot of applications too.
But if you are topstaining, you need to get the stain to stay on/in the wood, it's that simple. Yeah, there's another benefit - it makes shining the pipe up that much easier, so what's not to like?
ALL YOUR PIPE ARE BELONG TO US!
- SimeonTurner
- Site Supporter
- Posts: 750
- Joined: Wed Dec 24, 2008 7:46 pm
- Location: Denver, Colorado
- Contact:
Re: How thin is thin enough- Shellac
Apparently the fact that it's bug shit. Of course, if that's a problem for you, you're probably not going to be terribly thrilled about some of the other things involved with making/smoking a pipe.Sasquatch wrote: so what's not to like?
Me, personally, I'll rub bug shit smothered in Rad's shit all over a pipe if it'll make it look/smoke better. I do draw the line at Ernie's shit though...a man's got to have principles.
"It is noble to be good; it is still nobler to teach others to be good - and less trouble."
Turner Pipes Website:
http://www.turnerpipes.com
Of Briar and Ashes:
http://turnerpipes.wordpress.com
Turner Pipes Website:
http://www.turnerpipes.com
Of Briar and Ashes:
http://turnerpipes.wordpress.com
- staffwalker
- Site Supporter
- Posts: 391
- Joined: Thu Nov 23, 2006 8:00 pm
- Location: USA, texas
Re: How thin is thin enough- Shellac
Don't get me wrong, I have nothing against using Shellac. I tried it for a year or so and finally stopped altogether, not because I had a moral reason to do so but because I never found a method of applying which didn't, (at times), leave streaks, overlaps and bubbles. I have found extra buffing with brown Tripoli will produce a shine without Shellac. It takes me a couple extra hours to do so, however. I haven't used Shellac on smooths for two years or so. Just for the record, I have never had a problem with losing a topcoat with normal buffing. In order to buff off the topcoat, one would have to really bear down. Perhaps that's why I think using that as an excuse is 'double-talk'. No offense intended. bob gilbertSasquatch wrote:Bob I think the difference you're not indicating here is that there's such a thing as a shellac finish, where you apply layer after layer of shellac and are constantly re-dissolving the lower layers and sort of polishing as you go, and you wind up with umpteen layers of shellac and it's shiny as hell. Let's call this French Polish. What's going on with the pipes is nothing like that.
Yeah, I get a shinier finish when I use shellac, and that's because it offers a very smooth base for the wax, and has done some microscopic fill work on the wood, leaving a very smooth surface after polishing. But the amount of shellac on the pipe after the polish is.... god, it's miniscule.
Like Tyler (and probably totally unlike Tyler) I have moved away from shellac in a lot of applications too.
But if you are topstaining, you need to get the stain to stay on/in the wood, it's that simple. Yeah, there's another benefit - it makes shining the pipe up that much easier, so what's not to like?
Re: How thin is thin enough- Shellac
None taken, and in re-reading your post originally, I thought "Ya know, he didn't say he was against it..."
I stopped using shellac for similar reasons on my smooths. I found a weird water based emulsion that I have been having very good results with. Shellac in any quanitity can melt, rib, bump, pull etc under heavy buffing, and that's a drag.
What's neat is there's a hundred ways to get a good shine, and as far as I can tell, they all involve sanding really thoroughly at 220.
I stopped using shellac for similar reasons on my smooths. I found a weird water based emulsion that I have been having very good results with. Shellac in any quanitity can melt, rib, bump, pull etc under heavy buffing, and that's a drag.
What's neat is there's a hundred ways to get a good shine, and as far as I can tell, they all involve sanding really thoroughly at 220.
ALL YOUR PIPE ARE BELONG TO US!
-
- Posts: 1767
- Joined: Mon Jun 11, 2012 9:43 pm
- Location: Missouri
- Contact:
Re: How thin is thin enough- Shellac
And now of the dumb blonde question of the day......What brand of shellac does everyone use? Just curious, I guess.
Am I Calamity Jane or Annie Oakley??...depends on the day.
www.ladybriar.com
www.ladybriar.com
Re: How thin is thin enough- Shellac
Any flake shellac will do. Dissolve in methyl alc.
Stay away from Zinsser from Home Depot etc - it's full of weird propanols and stuff, not very "pure".
Stay away from Zinsser from Home Depot etc - it's full of weird propanols and stuff, not very "pure".
ALL YOUR PIPE ARE BELONG TO US!
-
- Posts: 12
- Joined: Mon Jul 02, 2012 6:10 pm
Re: How thin is thin enough- Shellac
HI SasquatchSasquatch wrote:Shellac melts at around 65 degrees C - far too hot to touch. So if anyone "melts" the finish on a pipe, they've burnt the inside of the bowl most likely.
There are certainly more durable finishes, and lots of them are reasonably compatible with pipe making. And you can slop a heavy coat of varathane on your next pipe if you don't like bug shit, longneckers, and just see how the customer likes it.
I think it's pretty important to note that no one is doing a "shellac finish" - french polishing a pipe is basically impossible. What we are suggesting is that some kind of hardening impregnator needs to be used to set the stain on a pipe.
The wood in the picture i posted had a shellac primer coat before I slopped varathane on it.
But it is not varathane .
But if i could slop varathane on there and make it look that good I would.
My last slop job went for 375.00
Your slam was rude
Longneckers
Re: How thin is thin enough- Shellac
Well Longneckers, you're entitled to your opinion. Everything in your first post was technically correct, and totally irrelevant to the discussion being had.
Those who use shellac here do so for many reasons, those who eschew it do not do so because it's "bug shit".
The finish you got on whatever it is you posted is glorious - looks like a tool handle? And what happens when pipe collectors find out that it's acrylic, varathane, epoxy enamel, or whatever the hell it is, is they'll say "Oh, that's not a good finish for a pipe." and they won't buy it.
So do as you please, finish as you please, but please understand that showing up here, making your what, 10th post? and basically telling us all that we're doing it wrong is ... not that welcome, to be honest. If you have a method and a material that you feel is superior, let's discuss it. But your post was nothing like that, it was a slap and dash job, designed to show us all that you are a superior wood finisher.
Here's an idea. Go make a pipe!
Those who use shellac here do so for many reasons, those who eschew it do not do so because it's "bug shit".
The finish you got on whatever it is you posted is glorious - looks like a tool handle? And what happens when pipe collectors find out that it's acrylic, varathane, epoxy enamel, or whatever the hell it is, is they'll say "Oh, that's not a good finish for a pipe." and they won't buy it.
So do as you please, finish as you please, but please understand that showing up here, making your what, 10th post? and basically telling us all that we're doing it wrong is ... not that welcome, to be honest. If you have a method and a material that you feel is superior, let's discuss it. But your post was nothing like that, it was a slap and dash job, designed to show us all that you are a superior wood finisher.
Here's an idea. Go make a pipe!
ALL YOUR PIPE ARE BELONG TO US!
-
- Posts: 12
- Joined: Mon Jul 02, 2012 6:10 pm
Re: How thin is thin enough- Shellac
Sasquatch wrote:Well Longneckers, you're entitled to your opinion. Everything in your first post was technically correct, and totally irrelevant to the discussion being had.
Those who use shellac here do so for many reasons, those who eschew it do not do so because it's "bug shit".
The finish you got on whatever it is you posted is glorious - looks like a tool handle? And what happens when pipe collectors find out that it's acrylic, varathane, epoxy enamel, or whatever the hell it is, is they'll say "Oh, that's not a good finish for a pipe." and they won't buy it.
So do as you please, finish as you please, but please understand that showing up here, making your what, 10th post? and basically telling us all that we're doing it wrong is ... not that welcome, to be honest. If you have a method and a material that you feel is superior, let's discuss it. But your post was nothing like that, it was a slap and dash job, designed to show us all that you are a superior wood finisher.
Here's an idea. Go make a pipe!
Well here is #11 post
How did i say everyone was doing it wrong ?
my 10th post OMG I have been again
All I was showing was a finished product and shellac was used .
The picture was a No bs here it is a finished product . I thought it looked good for being slopped on. well light up and chill "there" pipes and they were made to enjoy life.
longneckers