#1218 and #1219

[Charl]

I would really appreciate some critique on these 2. Any comments would be appreciated!
#1218:




and #1219:

[maxmil]

An impeccable job.
Best regards.
Félix

Un trabajo impecable.
Saludos.
Félix

[R.H.]

I really like the clean lines y that two wonderful pipes.

[Hudson]

Gorgeous!

[mightysmurf8201]

It may just be the lighting/reflection or angle, but on the first pipe it looks like the top of the saddle starts to taper a bit. Aside from that I think you've done a bang up job . I really like the birdseye on both pipes.

[wdteipen]

The stain choice on the first one doesn't fit well with the Cumberland stem and looks bland to me. I like the shape overall and it's very well executed.

I like the shape of the second pipe also. The only thing I see that could be improved on it is that the bottom line of the shank and stem could be more curved to match the top line; especially as it approaches the button. Nice work as usual.

[Charl]

Thanks, Wayne. I really need a lot of work on my stems, there are lots to improve on! Especially on bents and thicker stems, I really struggle with getting the flow right.