pipemakersforum.com

You guys know the drill. Go at it!












As always, thanks for your time and effort commenting my work!

Looks to me like the button is a little wider on the bottom than it is on the top. (From the side view.) That's all I can see.

That being said, I have a ways to go before my pipes look that good, so I should probably just keep my mouth shut...

The slot and button work could be sharper/more clean lines, but the pipe overall is really nice. That on is in my wheelhouse.

I really like the pipe, but I wouldn't call it a Devil Anse, if there is an accepted shape then yours is too fat, especially around the shank. Now if you were calling it a stubby cutty then I would say it is gorgeous, especially the finish, I love that.

The one thing that caught my eye immediately, is the bulge in the stem. I would have like the taper to run straight from button to shank in the sideview.
That said, it's well done. And that finish is stunning!

More contour in the cheeks. Striking finish!